February 22, 2022

Whereas Jewish law prohibits causing unnecessary pain to animals;

Whereas the Rabbinical Assembly’s Committee on Jewish Law and Standards has recognized that animals must be raised in humane conditions;

Whereas, in 2008, the Rabbinical Assembly and the United Synagogue of Conservative Judaism established the Hekhsher Tzedek Commission to bring the Jewish commitment of ethics and social justice directly into our food supply practices;

Whereas Rabbinical Assembly members have continued to point to the gulf between industrial food supply practices and our ethics and expectations of a kosher certification; 

Whereas shifts to our institutional food practices, such as reducing factory-farmed animal product consumption, would help us to better achieve our values;

Therefore be it resolved that the Rabbinical Assembly urge Jewish institutions to adopt food sourcing practices that better reflect our moral and religious values;

Be it further resolved that members of the Rabbinical Assembly create pathways to proactively engage constituents in education and ethical ideas and work towards bringing these values, actions and practices into our individual and communal lives;

Be it further resolved that our  Social Justice Commission create an ad hoc subcommittee to  revisit our work in the area of ethical food consumption with a focus on  sourcing of kosher-certified animal products and whether those sources meet our values;

Be it further resolved that this subcommittee expand upon a list of best practices for sustainability and ethical food practices; and

Be it finally resolved that this subcommittee report its findings to the Rabbinical Assembly membership at the 2023 Rabbinical Assembly Annual Meeting.

Comments

Hekhsher Tzedek failed in large measure because we put no material resources behind it. Providing advice is cheap. If we are serious about this effort, we should commit resources to promoting it from RA money, not only the discretionary fund contributions that the commission was forced to solicit in the oughts.

Sorry if this is a duplicate -- having trouble submitting. We should include a commitment from the RA's funds to pursuing Hekhsher Tzedek if we are serious about it. It failed back in the day because it was funded by money scrounged from rabbis' discretionary funds up against a well-organized opposition from people with deep pockets. Advice to others is free, but ultimately worthless. Jack Moline

This resolution sounds nice but is fraught with difficult problems, most prominently that of definition. The terms are so amorphous that I would not know what I am voting for despite the nice language. I would therefore vote no for this resolution.